How it works
Borehole Non-Return Valves and Water Hammer: What They Do and Why They Fail
By the WaterQuotes team · Published 2026-11-16 · 7 min read
If your borehole pump starts with a loud bang, or water dribbles from your taps for a few seconds after the pump stops, there is a good chance the non-return valve is not doing its job. It is one of the smallest and cheapest components in a borehole system, yet when it fails the consequences reach all the way from the pump at the bottom of the hole to the pipes inside your house.
What a Non-Return Valve Actually Does
A non-return valve (NRV) — sometimes called a check valve — is a one-way gate inside the rising main, the pipe that carries water from the pump up to the surface. When the pump is running, water pressure holds the valve open and flow passes through freely. The moment the pump stops, the valve snaps shut and traps the water column above it.
That trapped column matters. Without it, gravity pulls hundreds of litres of water back down the borehole the instant the pump switches off. The sudden reversal of that mass of water is what causes water hammer — a pressure surge that sends a shockwave through your pipework. You hear it as a bang or a series of knocks. Repeat this event dozens of times a day and seals fail, fittings crack, and pressure gauges die early.
Most submersible borehole pumps have a built-in check valve at the pump head itself. Many installations add a second valve higher up the rising main, sometimes at the surface where the pipe enters the pump house or storage tank. The two work together: the lower one protects the pump immediately on shutdown; the upper one keeps the surface pipework pressurised. For more on how the full system fits together — pump, tank, pressure switch — see our guide to borehole pressure switches and tanks.
Where Non-Return Valves Are Fitted
There is no single correct position; it depends on the depth of the borehole, the static water level, and the head pressure the pump works against. Common placement points are:
| Position | Purpose |
|---|---|
| At the pump outlet (factory-fitted) | Prevents immediate backflow into the pump on shutdown |
| Every 50–100 m up the rising main | Breaks the water column into sections, reducing hammer force |
| At the surface header | Keeps the above-ground pipework pressurised between pump cycles |
Deep boreholes — anything beyond roughly 60 m — usually benefit from at least one intermediate valve because the weight of the returning water column is simply too great for the pump-head valve alone to manage.
Signs That a Non-Return Valve Has Failed
The symptoms are fairly consistent, though they can be confused with other faults:
- Banging or knocking immediately after pump shutdown. This is classic water hammer from an unrestrained returning column.
- Pump starts with a loud thud or jolt. The pump re-starts into an empty rising main rather than against a pressurised column, causing a sudden pressure spike.
- Short cycling. A leaking valve allows water to drain back slowly, dropping pressure in the tank and triggering the pressure switch to restart the pump far too often. This looks almost identical to a waterlogged pressure tank — see our low borehole pressure troubleshooting guide to help tell them apart.
- Pump spinning backwards on start-up. A completely failed valve lets the water column reverse the pump impeller. If you hear a grinding or whirring sound in the first second or two of start-up, this is the likely cause.
- Water continuing to flow briefly after the pump stops. A small trickle at the tap after shutdown is normal if there is a surface-side NRV holding back the main column, but a sustained flow suggests the valve above-ground has failed.
If you are dealing with a pump that simply will not start or run correctly, our article on borehole pump faults and fixes covers the broader diagnostic process.
Why Non-Return Valves Fail
Most NRVs are made from brass, stainless steel, or engineering-grade plastic. They contain a spring-loaded disc or ball that opens under forward pressure and closes under reverse pressure. The failure modes are predictable:
Scale and mineral deposits. South African groundwater frequently carries dissolved calcium, iron, or manganese. These minerals precipitate on the valve seat and prevent the disc from sealing fully. The valve weeps rather than closing cleanly.
Spring fatigue. The return spring loses tension over years of repeated opening and closing cycles, especially in high-cycle installations where the pump runs many times a day.
Debris lodged in the seat. Sand, iron ochre, or pipe scale can wedge the valve partially open. This is more common in boreholes that were not properly developed after drilling — a process described on our borehole drilling overview.
Incorrect specification. A valve rated for a lower pressure than the system delivers will fail prematurely. This matters particularly in deep boreholes where shut-off head pressure is high.
Age. Plastic-bodied valves in aggressive groundwater may last only five to eight years. Brass and stainless variants typically outlast them but are not indefinite.
If a failed non-return valve has led to pump damage or you are not sure what else may have been affected, a proper site assessment is worth arranging early. Compare 3 free quotes from vetted borehole specialists — no obligation.
How Water Hammer Is Measured and Managed
Water hammer severity depends on three things: the length of the rising main (longer = more mass = more energy), the velocity of flow in the pipe, and how abruptly the valve closes or the pump stops. Installers manage the risk in several ways:
- Slow-closing valves. Some NRVs are designed to close gradually over a fraction of a second rather than slamming shut. They reduce the pressure spike significantly.
- Surge vessels or expansion chambers. A small air-charged vessel near the pump outlet absorbs the pressure wave. These are common on larger commercial systems but are increasingly fitted on domestic installations in areas with deep boreholes.
- Correct pipe sizing. Oversized pipe reduces flow velocity and therefore hammer energy. This is a design decision made at installation.
- Staged shutdown. Some variable-speed drives (VSDs) ramp the pump down rather than stopping it abruptly, giving the valve time to close against a diminishing flow rather than a sudden reversal.
Replacing a Failed Valve: What to Expect
Surface-mounted NRVs — those fitted at the header or pump-house pipework — can be replaced by a competent plumber or borehole technician without pulling the pump. The job typically takes an hour or two.
Valves fitted on the rising main below ground require the pump to be pulled. That means breaking the rising main at the surface, lifting the pump and pipe string in sections, and replacing the valve before lowering everything back down. The complexity depends on borehole depth and the weight of the assembly. For a 60 m installation with a relatively light stainless rising main it might take half a day; for a 120 m installation with heavy HDPE pipe it may take a full day with a proper pulling rig.
The valve itself is not expensive — as a rough guide, quality brass or stainless NRVs for domestic borehole use run from a few hundred rand to around R1,500–R2,000 for larger diameter units, but confirm current pricing with your supplier. Labour and equipment for a pump pull is where the cost accumulates. Any drinking-water components used should comply with SANS 241 (2024 edition), the South African standard for potable water quality, which also sets material suitability requirements for fittings in contact with water intended for consumption.
Getting two or three installers to assess your system means you can compare both the diagnosis and the repair cost before committing. Request free quotes from our vetted network — no installer pays to rank higher than another.
Preventing Valve Problems Before They Start
The most practical advice is routine: have a borehole technician inspect the above-ground valves and pressure readings annually. Many NRV failures are visible — corrosion, weeping, mineral staining around the valve body — before they become a full failure. Keep a log of how often your pressure switch cycles; a sudden increase in cycling frequency is one of the earliest warning signs that something in the pressurisation system has changed, and the NRV is a logical first suspect.
If your borehole was installed more than eight years ago and has never had its valves inspected, that inspection is overdue. A valve that costs a few hundred rand to replace proactively costs considerably more if it fails and allows the pump to run dry or spin backwards repeatedly before anyone notices.
Quick answers
How many non-return valves does a borehole system need?
Most domestic systems have at least two: one built into the pump head and one at the surface where the rising main connects to the pressure tank or distribution pipework. Deeper boreholes — typically beyond 60 m — often benefit from one or more intermediate valves spaced along the rising main to reduce water-hammer forces. The right number depends on depth, pump pressure, and the installer's assessment.
Can a failed non-return valve damage my borehole pump?
Yes. When the valve fails completely, the returning water column reverses the pump impeller. Repeated reverse-spinning stresses the shaft seals and bearings and can cause the pump to unscrew from the rising main if it uses threaded connections. Catching a failing valve early — usually signalled by water hammer or short cycling — avoids what can become a costly pump replacement.
Is water hammer from a borehole always caused by a non-return valve problem?
Not always. A waterlogged pressure tank (one that has lost its air charge) can produce similar banging because the pump short-cycles rapidly and the pipework absorbs repeated pressure spikes. A correctly charged pressure tank with a failed NRV produces hammer on shutdown specifically. A technician can usually distinguish the two causes by checking tank pressure and observing pump cycle behaviour.
What materials should a borehole non-return valve be made from?
Brass and stainless steel are the most durable options for South African groundwater conditions, where dissolved minerals and slightly acidic or alkaline water are common. Some engineering-grade plastics perform well in lower-pressure, shallower applications. Any valve used in a drinking-water system should be suitable for potable water use in line with SANS 241 requirements — confirm this with your supplier or installer before purchasing.
How do I know if my non-return valve is leaking rather than fully failed?
A partially leaking valve usually shows up as more frequent pressure-switch cycling than you would normally expect — the system pressurises, the pump stops, and then pressure drops slowly as water seeps back down. You may also notice the pump restarts unusually quickly after switching off, or that pressure readings at the tank drift downward between cycles. A complete failure tends to produce immediate water hammer on shutdown and a pump that starts with a bang.
Sources & notes
Pricing reflects typical Johannesburg market ranges and is confirmed by installer quotation. References: SABS
Ready to compare? Get up to 3 quotes from vetted borehole drilling installers in Johannesburg — free, no obligation.
Get 3 free quotes